Beyond the Urgent: How Nonprofits Plan Past the Fiscal Year
#193

Beyond the Urgent: How Nonprofits Plan Past the Fiscal Year

Chanda Smith Baker: Hello, community. You are listening to Conversations with Chanda, where leadership gets real and personal. This is where we cut through the noise to confront the issues shaping our world and our community, from power and justice to the heart of community change. Hosted by me, Chanda Smith Baker, President and CEO of the Saint Paul & Minnesota Foundation

Bethany Maki: Hi, everyone. I'm Bethany Maki, she/her pronouns, executive director of Progressive Multiplier Fund and Action Fund and CEO of our LLC, which is named Multiplier Effect. I am just the, the very privileged daughter of two wonderful parents, who were in the medical field and saw their frustration early, about where formal medicine ended and actual structural support for patients and caregivers began, and, learned early that the nonprofit sector, was really that social safety net and that, that stopgap, between where, medicine, in a hospital setting, in a formal setting ended and, the, the health journey began.

And so found my way very naturally into, healthcare nonprofits very early in my career, just a few years out of graduate school, and got to learn alongside, folks that have had such a huge impact on my career and the way I think, working on the ground, at a small HIV/AIDS task force and then at the, at chapter level at the Alzheimer's Association and then at the national office at American Diabetes Association, before I shifted into, being a consultant to, those kinds of, nonprofits.

That's, been my windy road from, the direct service healthcare sector and nonprofit and then, decided to move into, where I am now at Progressive Multiplier, because really wanted, my professional efforts as a fundraiser and as a leader to be, about, larger healthy democracy and change.

Chanda Smith Baker: From your early years to now, what do you think has evolved the most about how you see organizations or your own leadership?

Bethany Maki: I think what's evolved the most for me is how I see, the puzzle pieces. being an executive director right now of a smaller organization, versus when I was earlier in my career and had a, a single role or in one lane, I'm so fascinated and appreciative of the dance between functionalities within an organization and how that all has to be held together with a culture of psychological safety and empathy.

Chanda Smith Baker: Can you say more about those two? Because we're sitting, and I'm sitting right in Minnesota. the nation has been watching us- Yes ... over and over again. There's a lot that is in every environment that you're in, but particularly in the workplace- where you have, in some cases, maybe hopefully most cases, there's a level of diversity-

that allows for those life experiences to bring you more proximate to whatever the issue is that's being faced. And there's just a lot in our workplace. So- Absolutely ... can you say a little bit more about?

Bethany Maki: Yes. this, that hits home deeply for us. we are a very diverse team, in all the ways you would de- define diversity, y- age, race, gender, sexual orientation, lived experience, background, geography, all of the things, and I think it is our deepest strength, especially in working with frontline organizations because we always have someone, who has the experience that can, relate in some way to what the groups that we are here to support, are doing on the ground.

And I think that for, from a leadership perspective, being an executive director at an organization like this has really pushed us to put lived experience, as what we build on, and as a cornerstone. We know that a lot of the groups that we work with are dealing with, just the financial trauma of, what it means to work in the nonprofit sector.

And having a, a team made up of professionals who have worked, in this sector I think really brings that, sensitivity. So I think it's an important part of how we service the groups that we work with. And I think also internally, having such diversity, we've really strived to make Progressive Multiplier a place where empathy comes first and, where the, psychological safety is our first goal because we can't be a team and we can't do the work and support, the groups we're here to support without people feeling safe to bring their whole selves to the table- be honest, be candid, We've done a lot of focus on what are all of our growing edges, and how do we actually work on those together? We put those first as opposed to, the things we do great are, the things where we need to grow come first. and I think that that- that's led to a real culture of safe vulnerability for us.

Chanda Smith Baker: Yeah. What... If you could make it a little bit more tangible- do you have examples? Like, how do you know if your workplace is safe for your team?

Bethany Maki: So we of course have, like formal surveys and the sort of quantitative piece that we do. we work with Gallup CliftonStrengths a lot on that.

But I think for me as a leader, I know that my team feels safe when they can Challenge leadership and in a very productive way. bring disagreements to the table in a respectful way and in a generative way that's always about getting to a better place, of understanding, of service, that kind of thing.

So I think that's always, The fewer yeses that I get is always my litmus test of how safe, the team feels. and that we really lean into that generative tension that I think comes from having, a diverse workplace that centers lived experience.

Chanda Smith Baker: Yeah. Can we talk about the amount of confidence that requires in leadership?

Bethany Maki: Absolutely. I have spent probably the last two years really looking at leadership as a skill and a discipline versus just a, a title. position and leadership are two very different things. and that took me a while to learn, quite frankly. And that my job as a leader was setting that cultural tone and, really living out loud, when it comes to the mistakes and the learning in progress and, where my vision has fallen short, how that affects my team.

And really being, as I say, living out loud about what I see and what the effect, is. And I think that's, that's taken some doing and really living, into that for me now. I w- And I, actually identify myself as a leader, because it's a skill I've worked on, just like I identify myself as a fundraiser.

and that was a surprise to me, that journey.

Chanda Smith Baker: That's so interesting. So do you remember, do you have, a moment where you're like, "I'm a leader"? Yes. Or, can, will you share it with us? I'm so curious.

Bethany Maki: Yes. so I was fortunate to, be a fellow, at the, Rockwood Leadership Institute's, learning, Leading From the Inside Out.

Chanda Smith Baker: I

Bethany Maki: did that. Oh, really?

Chanda Smith Baker: Yeah, I did.

Bethany Maki: and it was one of those kinda transformational things for me, just A, holding the space to dedicate to leadership study. But for me, especially as a, a white leader, in the progressive movement, s- assumed I didn't belong there. and one of my- the, my fellow fellows, grabbed me by the shoulders and she was, and she said, that the ancestral intelligence that I brought into the room, gave me a unique perspective, and I needed to see it as a badge of ownership for what I n- the work I needed to do, not as a reason not to step into my leadership.

And that sat with me so deeply. and that it was part of my responsibility, to really hone this, this skill. And when I could start doing the things with my team that actually leading not from a place of positional authority for me was when I realized that I became, that I was a leader, and that I wasn't leaning on the fact that I sit in an executive director seat to lead my team.

that, that was the moment for me when I was like, that it was more of a shoulder-to-shoulder work,

Chanda Smith Baker: Yeah ...

Bethany Maki: of leadership. So that was it for me.

Chanda Smith Baker: What I wanna go here, and then I wanna go into progressive multiplier, a white woman in the progressive movement. Yes. So I come in, I come into a lot of scenes where someone's like, as a white guy," or, "As a white woman," or I identify very quickly that they're leading through a, filter of guilt.

Or, "I'm here, but should I be here? I'm here, but I gotta give other people space. I'm here, but..." can you... if you were talking to your people-

Bethany Maki: Yep ...

Chanda Smith Baker: what, what advice would you have? Because, for me, I would love for everyone to feel whole in the spaces- that I'm leading anyway.

Bethany Maki: I think, I would say that lived experience is lived experience for everyone.

And if, and part of centering lived experience, which is really the, the cornerstone of what I believe, the progressive movement is about in terms of being authentic to lived experience and making sure systems respond to lived experience, your lived experience counts, too. It doesn't count more. And that it, it is about, I am the, the granddaughter of a Klansman, and that, that is part of my lived experience.

And coming into my career as a fundraiser with all of the privilege and guilt, associated with my background, and of course, being a young person diving into, let me go raise money and fix all the, ills of the world," and that, that view that is so common. and I think, the, the tincture of time is really about you can't lead from guilt.

that putting your lived experience in the proper context of what does that, it then give you that you can use to serve beloved community.

So that, that is what I would say to my people.

Chanda Smith Baker: You just skipped very closely past that Klansman statement, but I think why it's important that you said it in the way that it is because it's just, it's a matter of fact.

And there are some things that are a matter of fact, and it, y- it has allowed you to both honor who and where your ancestors, where they were sitting, how they were acting, but it also could mean to me that, there was some work done in your own family between that point and where I hear you.

Bethany Maki: Absolutely. and I think that is part of the, where the living out loud, and especially as a leader, comes from for me is that isn't something that, isn't, gets, gets swept away, that that's part of the steps that got us here. and that- we talk a lot, about ancestors, and that is, very different, when that is the legacy that you carry.

But it can't translate into a, legacy of guilt. It has to translate into a legacy of learning, repair, purposefully growing, and always having that, that lens.

Chanda Smith Baker: So let's talk about Progressive Multiplier.

Bethany Maki: Sure.

Chanda Smith Baker: And what is it?

Bethany Maki: so Progressive Multiplier is a nonprofit intermediary. and we co-create the financial foundations for lasting justice, which we believe is really the cornerstone of a healthy, inclusive democracy.

Chanda Smith Baker: Talk to me about justice and democracy.

Bethany Maki: Yeah.

Chanda Smith Baker: How did you land with, that?

Bethany Maki: So I think when we think about the work of progress, the end game being beloved community, that justice has to be the thing that is, achieved, where everyone can, thrive. And in our, in the US, and being in a democracy, as a system that controls all of our sort of publicly held, assets, that a healthy and multiracial, inclusive democracy has to be built on justice so that all of those systems, serve all of the lived experiences.

Chanda Smith Baker: And when you say all, you mean all?

Bethany Maki: I do mean all.

Chanda Smith Baker: People have, they, PolicyLink came out with the all statement, and people were like, "What do you mean all? We should be working with the folks that have been most impacted by injustice." Or there's white people, they hear the word justice or inclusiveness, but they feel like- it doesn't mean them. You are clear about being both in the movement and it requires all for democracy to work.

Bethany Maki: I do mean all. and that's something that I think we have healthy debate about because especially given the work that we do, we work primarily with Black and Brown-led nonprofits that are building power, in their communities.

And if that works, those folks, who are more centered by our current democracy are not... if we work at the places in our democracy that are non-centered, then the communities that have not been centered in the narrative, in the investment, then we believe that then achieves inclusivity.

Chanda Smith Baker: Okay. So give us a little bit more on your approach to the work in that organization.

Bethany Maki: Sure. so we bring together funding. That's part of our intermediary role. We, raise funds, for the purpose of distributing them. So we bring together that funding and practical expertise, that we, coach, and provide strategic assistance to grantees, and really room to experiment, with revenue generation so frontline organizations can make more money that they control, and that, in the long term, strengthens their ability to pursue, their community-defined priorities.

Chanda Smith Baker: So I'm a CEO of a foundation with rules and processes and- ... everything, and you're talking about a different structure of how these organizations are funded.

Bethany Maki: Yes.

Chanda Smith Baker: So then my question is, based on what you just said, where do you think philanthropy needs to be the most disrupted in order to achieve it?

Bethany Maki: Oh, I love that question. so we definitely don't see philanthropy as the enemy. we see philanthropy as something that is over-relied on to finance the work, and we need diverse... Just like any financial portfolio, the more diverse it is, and the less sort of portion that one source owns, the more stable it is.

So we really think about diverse revenue and financial self-determination, are, the end games for the groups that we work with. So I would say where philanthropy needs to be disrupted is taking the perspective of the need to- fund both the work and the ability to get to a self-determining place, that those are, that those, those two things have to go together, that they are complementary pieces of work.

And what we see now is that philanthropy funds the program, but or they fund separately, capacity here, things like that, but it is not about actually long-term financial self-determination that keeps, that program and that mission going.

Chanda Smith Baker: If I a- so I'm gonna ask the same question, but on the side of either the executive leader or the fundraiser, because you're operating within a construct in which people understand and they engage in.

But what then needs to be disrupted in their thinking to get to a place of approaching this diverse funding model that you're suggesting?

Bethany Maki: within philanthropy or within-

Chanda Smith Baker: No ... nonprofits? I think about, This is what I'm thinking. I'll tell you exactly what I'm thinking. I'm thinking about the boards that I sit on, where they're like- we just need to have a really good fundraiser that puts more- ... requests into foundations. The volume isn't high enough for us to get what we need. Yeah. Or the executive who is pressuring the development person to reach out to the foundation leaders more often. Yep. so that it feels like there could be an overemphasis on raising traditional dollars through foundations- or through philanthropy versus what you're talking about is a different strategic approach and model.

Bethany Maki: Absolutely. I think that both for executive directors and fundraisers, they have to think about financial capital fundamentally differently. it needs to be a utility, and I don't think all capital has the same work.

I think we as executive directors, we... I just had my quarterly board meeting, and we're going over, financial reports and all of those kinds of things. All of our systems are set up to think about this fiscal year's operating need. That's it. That's the way that, funding is set up.

That's the way our internal management systems are set up. But we don't stop and think about, what is the capital that the mission actually needs long term. So I see financial capital in sort of four slices. protective capital, like, defending what we've already won or defending people. amplifying capital, where you're, you actually have enough money to do what you're doing today at its fullest expression and potential.

You're reaching all the people, not just 50% in your community or things like that. And I think there's resilience capital, so w- what money do you need to weather disruption in the economy, in political administration, in any of those things that cau- in election cycles that cause that ebb and flow, Of capital, financial capital into a nonprofit.

And then I think the bucket that we ignore the most is that self-determinational- determination capital, which requires executive directors to have more than a 12-month vision, and actually to know what the community needs to own and shape. I... So I think that the, the change that needs to happen within the nonprofit sector itself is to really, yes, there are the systems we have to work within because of our IRS status and all of those things, but to not be satisfied with, your financial, accrual-based financial reports aren't the end game.

It is about having a financial capital vision for what you wanna achieve and then make the systems fit

Chanda Smith Baker: For someone who is sitting on a non-profit board-

and I'm gonna use my experience here in the Twin Cities.

We've had crisis after crisis.

Bethany Maki: Yes.

Chanda Smith Baker: Or, we've had these moments where, poli- public policies, SNAP benefits are going away.

These things are- Yeah ... happening on our streets.

And the board wants to know, how are we dealing with it right now? Your team wants to know how you're dealing with it right now.

Bethany Maki: Yep.

Chanda Smith Baker: And when you have a season or seasons, right? it's been consistent for us, I would say, since 2020 for sure.

But let's- just go there. If you're reacting to something every single year, I think the muscle becomes what are we doing this year? And the tension- Yeah ... between being reactive to the immediate and urgent needs of community versus strategically thinking about the sustainability of an organization to do, the work.

H- how do you even have... I, this might be a big ask and a question, but do you even have questions, or could you support us if someone's on a board and listening, questions that might be good strategic questions, particularly in moments of, immediate demand, for them to be asking about what that vision might look like?

Bethany Maki: Yeah. I think it really is in the structure, especially I, sit on a, a board, as, well that has, definitely been, dealing with it. and we have to deal with the immediate need, right? No question. And then there is the sort of post immediate still in the current financial cycle needs. the lights have to stay on.

And then there is the what does it look like to actually live into a future that we wanna build now. And I think, part of it is the discipline to not allow the immediate fire, to derail the future we're trying to build. and that does take discipline, and it is completely contrary to how we as nonprofit professionals and, often board members are trained to think.

the way that I would, that I coach boards or nonprofit executive directors, it sounds very basic, but if we have a fire, let's spend three quarters of our time talking about that fire, and dealing with the immediate need. I'm calling to you in from Florida, so I- I very much understand. but let's reserve that 25% to talk about the after the fire and- The, we can't build that future that we wanna live in if we aren't talking about it and actually building it daily.

Ai-jen Poo and some others have talked about we're in this kinda multiverse moment where world one is, is crumbling, and the systems don't work anymore, and we have world two that we're existing in now, but we know it's not what we want, and then there's world three. And the right now is h- when we have to build the foundations for that world three.

So I think it really is in, the discipline, and that ebbs and flows of, when the fires die down, can you split that time to 50/50 that you're talking about the need now versus what you're building forward? And it, that, that affects every little operational piece, how you structure a board agenda, how you structure a financial report, things like that.

Yeah. So that, that's some of the geeky, nitty-gritty stuff that I get to do with our grantees is help them do that kind of training with their boards and put together those kinds of financial reports.

Chanda Smith Baker: Yeah, I really love it. And, I'm thinking about the work that creating a collective vision takes.

Or the amount of time That we should be as, as institution, as positional leaders thinking about, the day-to-day conversations versus times to like iterate and envision together-

the tension between the two. And then I'll close that, somewhat of a comment question is, the people that feel like the meeting is only productive if you have an action.

And so those sit counter to each other. And so what can you tell people that are like, "Look, I just want the, the one through 10, let's come out, let's have- let's have something in play," versus this sort of world three scenario, this universe of, three that you just talked about?

Bethany Maki: Yeah. It's funny, I don't think they're contrary necessarily.

That's a, a part of, I've been fortunate to, read, and get to have some interaction with Norma Wong, who's just an amazing, political strategist and, thinker. And that rigor is radical, right? And you can actually come out of the meeting about that big vision with, the action items.

They're not the immediate like, "Go send this email, go write this report"- action items, but they're the, w- we're working on a, a long-term vision, right now and, So I had a couple colleagues come down and we locked ourselves in a room for three days and came up with what we needed to do.

And now it's like, okay, we need this much money to start beta testing some of these things. So like that's the work right now is that, it isn't the big vision, it's how do we get the money to make sure that we can work on the big vision in an, in a supported way. Or it's let's start building our circle of who are the folks that we want in the room along this multi-year journey from now until, 2045, to be in the room with us along the way that need to be part of this purposeful ecosystem that we're, starting.

So I think it's just, it's, it- Being of two brains at the same time of this immediate, action item work that goes into my task list today, and then there is this sort of, s- lower burn. I'm a cook, so it almost feels like there is this, like, low and slow, cooking that's happening over here, where it is, not...

It doesn't feel as dynamic, but it takes just as much sort of rigor to make sure that it doesn't fall by the wayside.

Chanda Smith Baker: Yeah. part of your work is to help the nonprofits have some independent revenue.

Bethany Maki: Yep.

Chanda Smith Baker: can you talk about, like, why is that important? I think people will talk about it from a general operating or when- they talk about year grants, but you're really, you're talking about something, much bigger than that. Yes. not that it doesn't include that, but much bigger than that. But what is the advantage of having that?

Bethany Maki: Yeah. I always see independent revenue as, it is the revenue that lets you define your own agenda, 'cause even general operating support or unrestricted grants, just, it's still someone else's money.

It still comes with, "We have to spend it down by this time." It still comes with, "We can spend it in our C3 and not our C4." and that's, I'm a big fan of general operating support, and it's absolutely necessary and a critical piece to get, especially in that resilience capital space. but it is not money that you can completely define where it goes, when it goes, how you wanna invest it.

so there is this, this thriving element that actually requires incredibly That, it requires financial self-determination, and no grant will ever get you that. It's a piece to the puzzle of getting there, but it is not ever going to be money that you can, completely drive and be nimble with.

a- and so I think that's why independent revenue, regardless of how you raise it, is a critical layer to the financial capital stack.

Chanda Smith Baker: What is there diff- tell me the difference between-

Bethany Maki: Yeah ...

Chanda Smith Baker: resilience capital and independent revenue. Is there a difference?

Bethany Maki: I think resilience financial capital, regardless of the form it comes in, it's really about weathering the disruption, right?

Which is often what we lean on general operating support to do. it's the money that evens out the cash flow when our, temporary restricted net assets aren't, have some ebbs and flows to them. So resilience financial capital to me is about, I can go through a dry period, or a grant can get pulled because of an administration change, or, COVID can happen and my, I have a couple of fundraising streams get shut down overnight.

That is the money that, that is more steady state. It is in the bank money that helps us weather disruption. Where an independent revenue may contribute to resilience capital, right? that's your reserves, and if you wanna raise money into your reserves out of your independent revenue, great.

Absolutely can be part of a strategy. I think that's the thing, is that independent revenue can go anywhere you need it. so it can be, it can serve whatever purpose you need in the moment, and you get to say what that purpose is and be nimble to if the need in the moment changes.

Chanda Smith Baker: I imagine people are trying to contextualize this.

Do you have an example or a story of an organization that you've supported and, maybe that evolution or how they might have gotten to the point of getting more independent revenue?

Bethany Maki: Absolutely. so Vote ER is, a group that we've worked with probably for three years now. a- and they do, civic engagement in healthcare settings, because they, believe that there is a democracy, and having an inclusive de- democracy is actually a determinant of health.

and which I, I completely agree with. They go into hospital settings and, healthcare settings and help people actually register to vote, as part of their, healthcare and educate on that. Here is how federal and state funding actually feeds into healthcare that's available, in your neighborhood, and things like that.

h- when we started working together, they were 100%, institutional grant funded, a few major donors. And what we've worked with them on over the years is, diversifying that revenue so that they are, have built out a, an amazing small dollar donor program where they're actually, going after people like, like me, who support their mission, ac- going into the people who actually are directly connected to their, mission, the folks who work in hospitals that are familiar with them because of that work, and asking for small sustaining donations.

Give us $5 a month, $10 a month. They've also, launched a conference around their work where they bring together a lot of practitioners, and we're able to start incorporating corporate sponsorships into that as another form of revenue. and, all of that sort of exposure then unlocks more major donors and things.

So it's, it is that sort of slow burn, multiple year, just diversifying different forms of revenue. And now, so they now have far more strategic flexibility about communities that they wanna do outreach in, or experiments that they wanna run about, "Hey, could we organize, work around these kinds of physicians or in this kind of community?"

Chanda Smith Baker: A lot of times I, again, I'm sitting on these boards or around fundraising tables where- They're like, "Look, we're going after the large donor because- Yep ... like the prospecting, we don't have the team-

that can do this. Like once, once you get the donor and they're coming in at those r- like there's more of them.

Yes. It requires more time. is that the right thinking?

Bethany Maki: I ... The way we always teach and coach is that you gotta start with the organization that you are. Like the best fundraising is one that actually fits who you are now. So if you don't have a, like a mass base of people, then no, starting a small dollar donor problem, program probably doesn't make a lot of strategic sense.

And we can't just think about independent revenue as donations. It could be fee for service. It could be buying a building and creating a, a stream of income from, renting or services. It could like, it ... All of those things are, on the table. so and that's, I think that is what- We've really tried to do with the groups that we work with is that this isn't about building something that is on the side of what you already do.

It's the best fundraising is integrated into the work that you already do so that you're not building this thing over here, that's, not real fundraising because it, power is organized people and organized money. they go together. so it's just really depends on, the mission of your organization.

Major donors are usually the, a pla- a great place to start because they can provide some of that seed capital to do other things, because it's a, a big check right away versus a smaller dollar program which takes, three years to build, So- and I would argue that you need some of that money that materializes faster and some of that, that materializes slower but can be far stickier over the long

Chanda Smith Baker: term.

Yeah. I think part of the point here is where we started with the diversified strategy- Yep ... and really just understanding what's your vision for capital.

Bethany Maki: Absolutely.

Chanda Smith Baker: And, what I've heard you say is that vision has to go beyond an annual cycle.

Bethany Maki: 100%. And, like, how many times as a board member have you been asked to look at a financial plan that goes beyond, this year's fiscal or maybe next year's?

So I think that it's really changing how we, quote-unquote, "do business", and that financial strategy has to be presented along with mission strategy and has to look beyond the bounds of the year that's gonna get audited, because th- they take long run- runways to put together.

Chanda Smith Baker: Yeah.

Is it a different staffing model than what we're used to?

Bethany Maki: That's part of it, absolutely. we often think of executive directors are rarely trained in financial strategy, and chief financial officers are usually more accountants or, people that have finance backgrounds but, not necessarily fi- financial management backgrounds, not necessarily financial strategy backgrounds.

so I do think that we have really key skillsets that are missing, in small and mid-size nonprofits and even large nonprofits, in the progressive sector. I certainly see more of that in, the world where I grew up in, large healthcare nonprofits. But I think it is, I think there is an executive staffing sort of skillset, that we need to build out.

And then I also think that it is, in nonprofit we've talked about silos for decades, right? but it is actually functionally looking at what is that, that programmatic and the, the development need, Because that, that program strategy is how the mission comes to life and what's the, the capital strategy behind it.

I think when we stop thinking about "Oh, here's our annual fundraising goal," and actually tie it in a very intimate way to here's our program strategy that meets the mission, and here's the, the capital year over year needed, to make those big visions happen, I think that, that is transformational.

Chanda Smith Baker: Yeah. You're also using different language. You use capital stack.

Bethany Maki: Yeah. As a m- it's not fundraising. You're actually designing a, a financial capital stack. 'cause that's, that is how ... businesses don't talk about fundraising, right? They- they think about money as a utility that makes their vision happen versus this sort of like icky thing they have to do to keep the lights on.

It's an integral part of the strategy, and there is no reason that we can't harness the, that same thinking, to grow how our missions get delivered in the nonprofit space, while holding space for the financial trauma, and the money trauma is real, especially in the spaces that, that my team works in.

Chanda Smith Baker: Can you talk about how that shows up?

Bethany Maki: Oof.

Chanda Smith Baker: Oof

Bethany Maki: Yeah, no, that's ... It's a big one. It

Chanda Smith Baker: is, I

Bethany Maki: know So there is a lot of fear. so I usually work one-on-one with a lot of the d- executive directors that we work with. and there is, because there's always been a ... Money is just something we don't have enough of, and so there is this kind of lack of abundance mindset that I think feeds into this just baseline fear of this is something that, this is s- this is something that can make or break us versus something that we can control how we think about, how we bring in, how we match, how we spend to, the capital stack.

so I think there's just a lack of empowerment. I hate to use that word, I think it's ... But it is really legitimately fear-based. the other thing that we deal with, often is, just the very real, most of the groups that we work with are organizing, communities that are not, financially wealthy communities.

H- and then you're having conversations about money. that, that's real, and it's how do you put organized money, to the people that you're, you are working with in a way that is respectful of their, own financial situations, but not taking away their agency of they may very much want to invest in, their community in this way.

so I think it's for us about teaching a different, to sort of- Demystifying, taking the fear out of money, and really trying to turn money into this is a utility. this is like any other tool in the box that we can use for this mission. and I'll... I will be honest, there are some times I have completely stepped in it.

and it's... that's been one of those very, big learning edges for me over time is going into communities that carry very different kinds of financial trauma, and talking to them about fundraising and, organizing money. So-

Chanda Smith Baker: So when I think about the sector, it's getting more diverse-

Bethany Maki: in

Chanda Smith Baker: terms of who's getting, the lead role, right? Yep. New executives, smaller s- organizations that we're talking about. Leaders of color, leaders coming from communities- Yes ... as you've described, that have a certain relationship with money, or their communities have the relationship with money.

And again, I'm just gonna go back to governance for a second, because I've sat on so many boards where the decision on who's getting hired is being discussed. And they'll say, they don't have experience raising money." Yeah. Or they don't have the relationships, in the foundations. Oh, that, one drives me nuts.

And it drives me nuts too. And I want you to share with why it drives you nuts, because I watch people that have an incredible gift- of storytelling and connectedness get dismissed because they have not been part of the infrastructure.

Bethany Maki: Yep.

Chanda Smith Baker: as though they can't get there. And what do you think about that?

Yeah

Bethany Maki: it's, straight, that is the perfect example of white supremacy in fundraising culture. that's straight up what it is. And, so we have one program. We go at this a couple of different ways. we have a fellowship program, called our Emerge Fellowship Program, where we are trying to address the fact that especially fundraisers and leaders of color, are turning over at a rate of about every 18 months at the, the organizations where we work with.

And there are some real structural, and systemic oppression reasons why. so we have a fellowship program where we bring in, younger professionals and the organization's willing to hire them and train them both, on fundraising on this side and how to not be an awful employer of a fundraiser or as an executive of color.

because we need to make fundraising less white from an executive and a leader perspective. and I think that- Which

Chanda Smith Baker: doesn't mean, simply hiring people to make it less white. That's not what you

Bethany Maki: mean. Exactly. No. It is, we have to actually change why, is it this legacy white career path, and why are white fundraisers the ones who are looked at as, oh, they have all of the, these are the, the folks that have the, the deep Rolodexes show, showing my name, and the connections, and they are part of this infrastructure.

And it's like, if you don't change the infrastructure, all you're doing is perpetuating the problems that have made it what it is today. And I think that, we wanna make sure that, w- organizations get where fundraisers of color run into these institution- barriers at their own non-profits, where they don't get support from the boards the way they, should to open those doors.

So it's a, a different way of working. It's not the classic old fundraising model, you came in with your own connections. It's hiring, the best fundraisers are organizers. They're storytellers. I don't care if they've never raised a dollar, they are the people who can, actually sit down, make a case, and get you on board.

That's it. It has nothing to do with the fundraising skill, when you're talking about at that level. and that's what we want to... What we try to do is bring the sort of science of fundraising that, that really great organizers don't necessarily have exposure to, and giving them that. and then helping organizations understand why this kind of, fundraiser needs, needs a newer version of leadership from their organization and different structures and different kind of board, integration.

So but yeah, it drives me absolutely nuts when I see, organizations pass on really great organizers, a- as fundraisers 'cause it's just, it just, it's so shortsighted.

Chanda Smith Baker: Agreed. 18 months in the role.

Bethany Maki: Yes.

Chanda Smith Baker: You said 18 months. So I'd heard that statistic, and I remember sharing it with my team and I think my board chair- and saying, "This is something I've heard. this is something I've witnessed."

Bethany Maki: Yes.

Chanda Smith Baker: this is something I choose not to have in my life. so I think it's important for us to talk about the differences of who I am in leadership and what that means. And what do you think it's gonna take for us to make that statistic not

Bethany Maki: I think it is putting financial strategy and designing of a capital stack on equal footing through leadership size as the program. So that the work, they are... they have to go hand-in-hand, and actually hand-in-hand from minute one of the strategy. I think it's going to take executive directors thinking about their vision longer term, and in sort of being able to express it in fundable priorities, so that they are setting up their, the people who have to organize the money and build the program for success.

I think it's going to take boards reimagining their role, when it comes to revenue generation, in that, you are there to bring your power, to the board, and that means it d- it doesn't mean you need to write a check. I, I could... We could do an entire conversation about how awful give-get policies are and everything like that, but it's, the way I like to look at that today is you bring your power to the board, whatever that power and lived experience is, and part of that is who you know, how can you help build the capital strategy and the program strategy, in a way that, is authentic to the, skills and the doors and the, you know, the knowledge that you bring.

So I've been, working with, a group in Boston, to meet with each one of their board members and literally say "Okay, if these are the things we need to grow and get to a point of financial self-determination, how can you help us with any of these eight things?" hosting something, introducing us to someone, role-playing with the executive director so she can practice her pitches.

whatever it might be. but it's no one on that board gets to avoid the fact that y- the capital stack is your responsibility, even if, you were recruited for your programmatic expertise. So I think it's, it is a change at every level in how we view capital.

Chanda Smith Baker: Yeah. And what patience is required to get someone from perhaps a traditional model of fundraising to the one that you are- working on? how patient do you have to be? Like, it also assumes that, I think, is that, all of the outcomes don't happen in a calendar year either.

Bethany Maki: Oh, no. That's where that far vision comes from, that that world three piece. And that's why I think the vision is so important to, to have.

Otherwise you're just fundraising to, for an operating budget, right? So it k- the capital conversation changes when you can actually tie it to the bigger vision, and it's a slower burn, and it takes way more patience. but it's... fundraising isn't interesting when you are just, scrambling to cover an operating budget.

It isn't a strategic tool. It's a keep the lights on mechanism- versus, capital as a utility to, feed a bigger vision. That somebody can get behind. That s- has a role for somebody, to play. And so I think that it is resetting that, we have our one-year vision and we have our three or our five or whatever.

It's different for different, types of organizations, but it is, having the patience to build it and organize people around that and then making sure that it's like we are slowly but surely, reporting out on our, progress to that. So it's almost like running two, two tracks at one time.

sort of the world two and the world three- Yeah ... is what it feels like to me as an executive director today. and I, but I do think it, it requires a patience that, you know, in a world where we are dealing with fires in front of us we're not used to exercising. So I think there's just a, a duality required, across the board for the world we wanna build.

Chanda Smith Baker: Yeah. Do you have any other sort of characteristics of organizations or, capacities that they need to be able to go down this journey that you all are working towards?

Bethany Maki: Yeah.

Chanda Smith Baker: So patience is one you said.

Bethany Maki: Patience is definitely one. a willingness to, fail, and I think that is one of the hardest that, The hardest ones that we encounter because, again, the groups that we work with, failure isn't really an option, like we are on grantee calls and we- one of our groups, I was on the phone with them, and I was like, "It sounds like you're outside and, walking around. What's up?" And she's like, "I'm looking for my staff because I think they were, taken by ICE." that's our daily reality, with the groups that we work with.

And, so it's really hard to think about world three and strategy. So I think that it is, this is something we're building, and this isn't there's a set model, and we are gonna have to, lean in and fall, sometimes. And I think that knowing that falling isn't failure and that it's just part of this developmental cycle, because our grantees don't have the option to fail when they're, literally trying to save lives and democracy.

so I think that operational failure muscle is one, patience is one. I think a willingness to that nothing is sacrosanct. It takes- a certain agility and willingness to change, whether it is staffing structures or, who's on your board, how you relate to your board, the story you're telling about the work you do.

we have a lot of sort of, things that are sacrosanct, and it's like, "Oh, we've done that for years, and it brings us this money or da, da." That it's like, is it costing you something to not change? And to, to constantly be asking that. so I think those are, the big ones that I can think of.

Chanda Smith Baker: What about empathy?

Bethany Maki: That's the center of it all, in that, empathy to me is... Empathy is the precursor to justice. Michael and I, Michael Tennant, who wrote The Power of Empathy, which has been a, a transformational book for us here at Progressive Multiplier, that's what I always say to him is why I think the empathy work is so important to anyone working in this sort of justice and democracy space.

because if it isn't, if the work isn't rooted in actual authentic empathy, it will never work.

It can't be performative. It can't be because it's the quote unquote "right thing to do." it has to be empathy driven and centered, and that makes all the rest of it easier. the failing and the, the being, being willing to burn things down if they're not working and all of that.

Chanda Smith Baker: Are there practices that an organization can have to develop an empathy-

muscle?

Bethany Maki: Oh, yeah. I, went to a book signing, with the author I just mentioned, Michael, on Valentine's Day in 2024, and, I, I walked up to him and I was like, "I wanna operationalize empathy at my organization. Can you help me do that?"

and he looked at me like I was a little nuts, and that, that may actually be, true, but- so, what we did, and I think this has to start, literally from somebody's day one at an organization, but, we really dug into empathy education about what does it mean to actually bring empathy into the workplace.

we think about that a lot in our personal relationships, but what does it mean in a professional setting? 'Cause it operate, it operates a little differently. A- and what would it require of our culture norms, like both our collaboration standards, how we work together, as well as our cul- cultural norms, how we communicate.

What it, what would it take to change those so that they were empathy first? What policies need to change? Things like that. and then we re, we redid our entire orientation and onboarding to be very empathy centered, so we start with things like talking, like on day one at Progressive Multiplier, we don't talk about Progressive Multiplier, we talk about your personal ecology.

how do you manage your load and your time and your energy and your state of being so that you can thrive in this very difficult work? We talk about how we team, from the little things like- Here's how, long it ta- you should take to answer somebody's email to, what are our team traditions, and, like, all those things that, that feed into camaraderie and psychological safety.

So building empathy, into an organization t- is a, it's an everyday practice. We are not masters of it yet, for sure. we are building our skillset. But I think it's the intentionality of it, and that it is always the first lens that we put, the first test we put to everything we build, is that, is this truly empathy centric?

Chanda Smith Baker: As we wrap here, if there are folks that are curious about the organization, the work that you're leading- do you have a place that they should go to find out more?

Bethany Maki: Absolutely. progressivemultiplier.fund, is our website. Soon to be going through a, a lovely facelift, so please come check us out.

And of course, all of our social channels are linked there at the bottom. Feel free to follow me on LinkedIn. I do a lot of publishing, and talking about what we're doing at Progressive Multiplier and how some of these topics of financial resilience and empathy play into that work.

Chanda Smith Baker: Thank you for listening to Conversations with Chanda, hosted by me, Chanda Smith Baker, President and CEO of the Saint Paul & Minnesota Foundation.

To hear more conversations with change makers, visit conversationswithchanda.com, conversations with C-H-A-N-D-A.com, or find us on YouTube or wherever you get your podcasts. If you'd like to learn more about the work at the foundation, please visit spmcf.org.